Just Listed: Renovated Old Town Key West Pool Home — 1215 Margaret Street
Florida Keys Shane "Waterfront" Wilson March 27, 2025
Florida Keys Shane "Waterfront" Wilson March 27, 2025
Welcome to 1215 Margaret Street, a beautifully restored piece of Key West charm that blends historic character with modern-day luxury. Located in one of the most desirable neighborhoods—Old Town, right on the edge of Casa Marina—this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath pool home is exactly the kind of property that captures the spirit of island living.
Originally built with classic Key West architecture in mind, this home underwent a full renovation in 2019. That means you get the best of both worlds: preserved details like tongue-and-groove ceilings, wood floors, and pecky cypress accents—all upgraded with impact windows, a tankless water heater, in-home laundry, and a sleek kitchen featuring granite countertops and stainless steel appliances.
The heart of the home is the open-concept kitchen and living area, crowned by vaulted ceilings and anchored by a wall of accordion glass panels that open directly to the pool courtyard. It’s the kind of setup that invites in the island breeze and makes everyday life feel like a vacation.
Just across the pool, you’ll find a charming guest cabana with its own half bath and outdoor shower—perfect for hosting visitors or setting up a serene work-from-home space.
Step out your door and you’re just blocks from the best of Key West. El Siboney (a local favorite for Cuban food) is right around the corner. Walk to Truman Avenue in minutes. Beaches, galleries, and nightlife? Also just a short stroll or bike ride away. You’re in the heart of it all, without being stuck in the middle of the buzz.
Whether you’re looking for a luxury primary residence, a second home, or a vacation rental opportunity, this home checks all the boxes. The current owners have used it part-time and successfully offered it as a vacation rental—so flexibility is built right in.
If you’re dreaming of a poolside retreat that blends comfort, charm, and Key West cool, 1215 Margaret Street is ready to welcome you home.
Have questions or want to see it in person? I’d be happy to give you a private tour—just say the word.
Florida Keys
The Florida Keys is not a market where generalist experience translates directly.
Southwest Florida
The name says it all — Town and River sits at the intersection of community and waterfront access.
Florida Key
Some people don’t do rough water, so knowing I can switch sides in minutes is huge.
Southwest Florida
Huge menu, waterfront seating, and an upstairs bar with panoramic views over the bay.
Florida Keys
And when you’re ready to take the next step, reach out. We can tour by land — or by water.
Southwest Florida
Buying a waterfront home in Southwest Florida sounds simple—until you’re actually doing it.
Southwest Florida
Now they’re in their 60s, 70s, even 80s, sitting on piles of cash, but they can’t enjoy it.
Florida Keys
It’s ideal for buyers who want luxury + flexibility + boating all in one place.
Southwest Florida
Island Park offers larger lots, fewer restrictions, and a central Fort Myers location.
Decades of waterfront expertise, deep local roots, and a passion for the Florida lifestyle define every client experience. The Shane “Waterfront” Wilson combines extensive real estate knowledge with unmatched insight into the Florida Keys and Southwest Florida markets—helping buyers and sellers navigate every step with confidence and ease.
Get In Touch With Our Team
SHANE "WATERFRONT" WILSON
ADDRESS ISLAMORADA 85960 OVERSEAS HWY STE 4 ISLAMORADA, FL 33036 FORT MYERS 7270-4 COLLEGE PKWY FORT MYERS, FL 33907
