November 19, 2026
The tarpon at Robbie's started with one fish. Keys Weekly's 50th-anniversary story on the marina tells how a hurt young tarpon named Scarface spent six months healing in a bait tank. After it was released into the marina it never left, and before long other tarpon were schooling around the docks waiting to be fed. Today Robbie's says more than 100 tarpon come by every day.
Most of us have walked a houseguest down that dock at least once. This season Robbie's is worth more than the usual quick stop. Florida State Parks posted that as of Nov. 11, 2026, the boat dock at Indian Key Historic State Park is open and the park is back to normal hours. Indian Key is only reachable by water, and Robbie's is one of the two kayak rental outfits the state lists for getting there. That means one dock on Lower Matecumbe can now set up four different days: the island, the tarpon, the reef or bay, and Lignumvitae. Which guest gets which day depends on the clock, so this guide runs in clock order.
Robbie's lists daily hours of 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. Its tarpon page posts $2.50 a person to walk the dock and $5 for a bucket of bait. Check the price at the booth, because posted prices change. Warn the kids that the pelicans want that bait too. Robbie's FAQ asks visitors not to feed them.
The early dock walk is the best fit for relatives who aren't getting in a kayak. The Hungry Tarpon's posted breakfast runs from 6:30 to 10:30 a.m. Monday through Saturday and until 11 a.m. on Sunday. So you can feed the tarpon, eat breakfast and be back home before most of the house is up. The menu is also a quiet piece of Robbie's history. Keys Weekly reports that the restaurant grew out of the old bait-and-tackle shop, and its kitchen now fills the space the bait shop used to occupy.
Before you leave, point out the small concrete house in the middle of the parking lot. According to the same Keys Weekly story, the Starck family built it as their home in 1946, back when the property was the Walter Starck Fishing Camp. The doorjambs inside still carry ink marks recording the heights of the Starck boys as they grew, and later the heights of Reckwerdt children and grandchildren. The Reckwerdt family has run Robbie's for 50 years. They bought the property from the Starcks in 2012, and Michael Reckwerdt heads operations today. Most visitors drive right past that house. Your guests won't.
The Indian Key paddle is the one to plan around, because of the rental hours. Robbie's Kayak Shack hands out kayaks from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. and wants them back by 4:30 p.m. Its current rates are $50 for a single and $60 for a double. The rental comes with a life jacket, paddle, orientation and map, and the Kayak Shack recommends heading out first thing in the morning if Indian Key is the goal. It puts the paddle to the island at about 20 minutes.
For guests who would rather launch from the highway, the state's Lignumvitae kayak guide measures 1.66 miles round trip from Indian Key Fill to Indian Key. That's a comfortable morning for a paddler who has some experience.
The island is open from 8 a.m. to sunset every day of the year. Entry is $2.50 a person, paid in cash at the iron ranger near the kayak launch or in advance online. Bring small bills. The history is the reason to go. The state notes that in 1836 Indian Key became the first county seat of Dade County, and that the island's 11 acres hold the ruins of an early-1800s town that made its living salvaging ships wrecked on the nearby reefs. Your out-of-state guests probably have no idea that Miami's county government started on a speck of land they can see from the Overseas Highway.
If a guest wants to go out without paddling, Florida Keys Boat Rentals runs out of Robbie's. Its two-hour, 15-foot Carolina Skiff for two people is listed at $160.18 at checkout. That boat is limited to the bayside, with Indian Key allowed as an exception. Four-hour rentals start at $205 for a 15-foot skiff and go up to $350 for a 21-foot fishing boat or a 24-foot deck boat. The company requires prior boating experience and gives an orientation before you leave the dock.
Lignumvitae Key is the guest-day that depends most on the calendar. Lignumvitae Key Botanical State Park is open 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., Thursday through Monday. It charges $2.50 a person to enter plus $2 a person for a tour, and it is only reachable by boat or kayak. The state lists ferry service from Robbie's on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays. The ferry operator's current listing is a $65-per-person charter that leaves at 1:45 p.m. and picks up at 3:30 p.m., with entrance and ranger-tour fees included.
That gives the long weekend after Thanksgiving, Nov. 27 through 29, three ferry days: Friday, Saturday and Sunday. The state park page currently says ranger-guided tours are unavailable and offers a self-guided brochure instead. Call before you promise anyone a guided walk.
Strong paddlers can get there on their own. The state's kayak guide measures 2.84 miles from Indian Key Fill to Lignumvitae's kayak landing. With Robbie's 4:30 p.m. kayak return, that's a trip that has to start in the morning.
Every holiday house seems to have one relative who came to catch something. Captain Michael's party boat at Robbie's runs three trips: 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. for $100 a person, 2:30 to 6:30 p.m. for $75 a person, and a night trip from 7:30 p.m. to 12:30 a.m. for $100 a person. Bait, tackle, rods, the license, fish cleaning, bathrooms and a shaded cabin are included. The afternoon trip is the cheapest of the three. It also brings the angler back in time for dinner and leaves the morning free for a kayak or breakfast with everyone else. Robbie's has private and split charters too, but it doesn't post prices for those, so you have to call.
Keys Weekly lists the other ways out from the same docks: backcountry and offshore charters, snorkel trips, eco-tours, kayak and WaveRunner tours, and Transparensea, which it calls Islamorada's only glass-bottom boat. The paper also describes the docks as a gateway to Florida Bay, the coral reefs, Alligator Reef Lighthouse, Lignumvitae, Indian Key and the San Pedro Underwater Archaeological Preserve State Park. Few addresses in the Upper Keys can put a guest on that many different kinds of water within an hour.
Once the kayaks are back, the open-air shops are a good place to wait while the rest of the group catches up. Robbie's lists live painting by Barbara Weingardt, usually on weekdays and some Saturdays, plus Tim Rahn Photography, fresh coconuts, the Bead Shack, the Glass Shack, Niknax, Charli's Ice Shack and the marina shop.
The Kayak Shack also runs a two-hour sunset tour from $50 and a two-hour mangrove eco tour from $60. Public tours need at least four people. A holiday houseful reaches four without trying. The Hungry Tarpon serves lunch and dinner until 9 p.m., so the sunset group can come off the water and order. The menu lists tuna sliders, a Mahi Reuben and pan-seared salmon. The Trailer Trash Bloody Mary, which Keys Weekly calls award-winning, works as both the morning order and the evening one.
All of these clocks lead to one practical plan for a full house over the holiday weekend:
Robbie's doesn't post separate holiday hours. Call ahead on Thanksgiving Day and through New Year's. The tarpon will be there either way.
Shane is a Florida Keys native and a longtime boater, and the Shane "Waterfront" Wilson Team works out of an office in Islamorada. If a houseguest finishes the Indian Key paddle and starts asking what Islamorada is like from a dock of their own, our Islamorada neighborhood page is a good place to start. When they're ready to talk channels, bridges and how far a given canal really is from open water, get in touch and we'll take it from there.
Florida Keys
Shane “Waterfront” Wilson introduces Rachel Foreman, the newest Florida-licensed Realtor on his Keys team. Real estate experience, shared values, and a true people-fir… Read more
Florida Keys
Before I show a Florida waterfront home in the Keys, Cape Coral, or Fort Myers, I ask what boat you want. Draft, bridge height, and tide decide the neighborhood.
Decades of waterfront expertise, deep local roots, and a passion for the Florida lifestyle define every client experience. The Shane “Waterfront” Wilson combines extensive real estate knowledge with unmatched insight into the Florida Keys and Southwest Florida markets—helping buyers and sellers navigate every step with confidence and ease.